I’m new to the language, and although I like so many aspects of Julia, I am struggling to start using it. I come from Python mostly, but have been looking for an alternative in which low-level function speed can be accomplished easily if needed, but high level implementation speed is also high. Julia seemed to fit the bill, at least on paper. In Swift, I loved how clean my code became because XCode helped my by scanning all my arguments and complaining beforehand that something wouldn’t fit. Also I made tons of use of extending existing objects, for chains like
line.mirror(along: axis).drawInContext(ctx) and I thought this would be similarly possible in Julia, when you are already annotating types and often know exactly what to expect in a certain place. (Of course keeping it general wherever possible.)
I mostly do data analysis, experiment design and plotting in Python, or specifically in Jupyter Lab. With all the packages that there are, it’s hard to keep track of all the available functionality. Especially using matplotlib, numpy, and comparable big modules.
So my usual process is iterative. I might plot a figure like this:
fig, ax = plt.subplots(1) scat = ax.scatter(x, y)
Now I have the
scat objects, which of course have tons of methods bundled. So often, I will type
scat. and then tab to give autocomplete suggestions. This way I can really quickly scan the available functionality, basically only stuff that has to do with this specific object. I might learn that there is a function to set marker color, or whatever.
In Julia, this is much harder. Because methods never come bundled with the kinds of objects they’re meant to be used on, I see myself in front of a sea of functions without an idea what I have available. I know that there is
methodswith, but this gets tiresome pretty fast if you have to use it a lot. My mental load is always relatively high, trying to remember, what was this function that I could call with a
DataFrame as the first argument that did something related to aggregating, instead of doing
df. and filtering the suggestions quickly.
In many code examples I see that people are pulling tons of functions into the global namespace with
using, which is comparable to do
from xxx import * in Python. This is pretty bad practice in my opinion, because reading the code you can often not know where a certain function being called is from, you would have to execute and trace which method was dispatched.
How do you deal with these issues, maybe there are better workflows that I’m not aware of? This together with the sometimes very long precompilation times make Julia hard to justify for myself, even if I love the type mechanisms and would like to harness the high performance.
Thanks for your suggestions!