I’m not sure I really have a lot more to say on this topic.
I just think that posting unnecessarily long essays is disruptive to conversation, and I think that LLMs supercharge this propensity, and makes engagement with these posts feel even more useless. As I’ve said previously in another thread, I see the guideline about not posting generative AI outputs as really a subset of an existing rule urging people to be concise.
I think that while it often feels like something you arrived at with the help of your LLM is especially clear, the experience of others is often the exact opposite.