Could double summation be implemented without JuMP?

General Usage
1

Hello, I encounter a problem when trying to convert these(Python) to Julia:

delta_TRC = [sum((i - TRC)**2) for i in TRC]
        return sum(delta_TRC)

I found that the syntax of sum function provided by JuMP is very similar to these, but it is possible to implement only with the standard function ( whose syntax: sum(f, itr; [init]) )?
I am new to both Python and Julia, so I would appreciate if you explain the issue in detail…
Thank you.
The following is for reference, if needed:

from scipy.optimize import minimize 
class Portfolio:
    def __init__(self,port_a,port_b,port_c,port_d):    
        self.port_a=port_a
        self.port_b=port_b
        self.port_c=port_c
        self.port_d=port_d

        self.df=data[["Date",port_a,port_b,port_c,port_d]].dropna().reset_index(drop=True)
        ret=self.df[[port_a,port_b,port_c,port_d]]
        self.Rcov=ret.cov()
        self.cov=np.array(ret.cov())     

    def risk_budget_objective(self,weights,cov):
        weights = np.array(weights) #one-dimension array
        sigma = np.sqrt(np.dot(weights, np.dot(cov, weights)))  
        MRC = np.dot(cov,weights)/sigma  
        TRC = weights * MRC
        delta_TRC = [sum((i - TRC)**2) for i in TRC]
        return sum(delta_TRC)
2

Hello and welcome to Julia!

In short, the answer is: yes, you can do the same thing in base Julia than what Python+Numpy allows, with almost the same syntax.

The only syntactic difference lies in sum((TRC - i)**2). In this expression, i is a number (a scalar), TRC is an array of such numbers, and in this context the computation is supposed to mean:

  • tmp1 = TRC - i build the array obtained by subtracting the number i to every element of TRC
  • tmp2 = tmp1**2 build the array obtained by squaring tmp1 elementwise
  • sum(tmp2) compute the sum of all elements in tmp2

You see here that the arithmetic operations used to build tmp1 and tmp2 above are to be understood as elementwise operations; they are not simple operations between scalar numbers. This is where languages differ:

  • plain python lists do not allow this
    • [1,2,3] - 1 is an error
  • for numpy arrays, arithmetic operations are implicitly considered to be elementwise
    • numpy.array([1, 2, 3]) - 1 == numpy.array([0, 1, 2])
  • Julia allows to do this without any library, but you need to be more explicit by using dot operators
    • [1,2,3] .- 1 == [0,1,2]

Apart from the need to “dot” the operators (and the fact that power is denoted by ^ in Julia), the same syntax is supported:

julia> TRC = [1.0, 2.1, 3.2]
3-element Vector{Float64}:
 1.0
 2.1
 3.2

julia> delta_TRC = [sum((i .- TRC).^2) for i in TRC]
3-element Vector{Float64}:
 6.050000000000001
 2.4200000000000004
 6.050000000000001

julia> sum(delta_TRC)
14.520000000000001

You can even write the double summation in one expression, which could be more performant:

julia> sum(sum((i .- TRC).^2) for i in TRC)
14.520000000000001
2 Likes