Why is seek zero-based?

To go to the start of an IOStream, you have to do seek(io, 0). Why is this? I just spent about 30 minutes trying to debug an error caused by using seek(io, 1) instead.

1 Like

It’s just the standard convention for file positions across virtually all languages: refer to an offset relative to the start of the file (and hence be zero-based).

This convention is used even in languages like Matlab (fseek), Fortran (fseek), R (seek), and Lua (file::seek) that are otherwise 1-based by default, so it would be weird for Julia to differ.

8 Likes

Thanks Steven, that seems reasonable.

Perhaps a mention of this would be handy in the docs for seek.

2 Likes

Sure, you can do it yourself by opening a pull request for Julia! :slightly_smiling_face:

Note also that to go to the beginning of the stream you can use seekstart.

4 Likes