I don’t have any experience with other languages, and I was surprised to see “Hello World” produces this big standalone executables in Node.js. Julia is not far off then.

PackageCompiler.jl v2.1.5 + julia 1.9.0-rc2 + "Hello World!" = 408 MB = 309 MB (julia 1.9) + 99 MB (sys.dll) + 76 KB (JuliaHello.exe)

[image] GitHub - tshort/StaticCompiler.jl: Compiles Julia code to a standalone... Compiles Julia code to a standalone library (experimental) - GitHub - tshort/StaticCompiler.jl: Compiles Julia code to a standalone library (experimental) 8.4KB

[image] woclass: PackageCompiler.jl v2.1.5 + julia 1.9.0-rc2 + "Hello World!" = 408 MB = 309 MB (julia 1.9) + 99 MB (sys.dll) + 76 KB (JuliaHello.exe) Hopefully will get there with attempts in 1.10 and more focus on this goal going onward. [image] jling: 8.4KB Yeah but we don’t get …

What language features do you want for a program that just prints “Hello, world”? If you want a small executable you can get it, but then you don’t get the language runtime features (but you don’t need them). If you want all the language runtime features you can have those but that’s a big binary.

A program could take just those parts of the runtime that it uses, and help the programmer understand where in the program they’re requiring each feature.

If we’re going to figure this out, we need to find a better example than “Hello, world”. There are a dozen languages that can do “Hello, world” better than Julia, including COBOL. IDENTIFICATION DIVISION. PROGRAM-ID. hello. PROCEDURE DIVISION. DISPLAY "Hello, world!…

Not that it matters, but in what sense is that better?

More modern, user-friendly syntax, no doubt about it.

[image] Do Garbage Collectors necessarily make code slow? Well, the executable only 17 KB, for starters. So twice the size of the executable from StaticCompiler.jl :wink:

Exactly. We can already make a smaller Hello world program than that from Julia and the program is considerably simpler.

Standalone "Hello World" Executable size comparison to Node.js

Offtopic

Topic		Replies	Views
Building stand-alone helloworld produces many dlls, being 200MB big New to Julia	37	6509	November 18, 2021
How do I build an executable from my (hello world) simple script? General Usage	3	946	October 18, 2020
Any plan for small executable file New to Julia question , package	17	4364	August 31, 2022
PackageCompiler - size New to Julia	3	924	April 26, 2019
How fast ist a binary file from packagecomplier.jl and what is its file size Performance performance	3	2034	December 19, 2020

Standalone "Hello World" Executable size comparison to Node.js

Related topics