I can’t use the names I want to use because it puts the names directly in the namespace. I need to go back and forth between strings and enums easily.
Override Base.show for enums doesn’t appear to work.
I don’t want to put it in a little module by itself to namespace it because I can’t use that same name for both the module and the enum which causes confusion that I have to use X for type but Y.z for values.
@enum’s are just numeric constants, but the @scopedenum macro does some magic with a struct inside a module, so apparently something is going on. I just ran into it yesterday and haven’t reported it anywhere.
Right, there are solutions for that. However, the problem is the other bullet points and I have two enum’s that have the same value: EnumA x and EnumB x and need to use them both in the same code, but because enum’s aren’t namespaced, you can’t. It’s that I kept trying different solutions to make enum’s work and every time I tried something else I ran into another problem such that it wouldn’t work.
As for how minor it is, depends on how you look at it. Code needs to be as readable as possible for maintenance, but… conventions are required to be known in some cases, apparently this is one of those situations.
I was asking this question in case there was new information that solves all these issues that I hadn’t found yet but was known by the community (I’m new here). But, I think you’re right, the baremodule approach seems to resolve the most number of issues. And… I just now stumbled across this: GitHub - kindlychung/SuperEnum.jl: Julia enum made nicer which appears to make the bare module approach easy to do.
Thanks. I did see that announcement, though I notice it doesn’t solve the third bullet point: The namespace and the type name are different: MyEnum vs. MyEnum.T. I understand that might be impossible to solve, though, so it looks nice. I’ll give it a try. As for what it does above SuperEnum, the EnumX README says SuperEnum “doesn’t give you Base.Enum s” though I’m don’t know the ramifications of that.