To be clear at the top, I don’t have practical or theoretical background in language/compiler/memory management design. This is not a proposal for an improvement to Julia’s garbage collection. I have one of those “isn’t the solution simple?” ideas that only a total novice could think. Why does GC n…

Object lifetime is decoupled from lexical scope in Julia. E.g., the last reference to an object might be buried in a linked list. Hence the need for garbage collection to walk the object graph. Concurrent garbage collectors are well known. e.g. Dijkstra’s tri-color collection algorithm dates back t…

you are only collecting objects in the “old generation” which have fallen out of scope for all processes I’m a bit confused by what you mean. I’ve understood the old generation as being those objects that have repeatedly survived the collection process because they are still alive. But you seem t…

If you know that an object isn’t in scope anymore you don’t need a GC to free it, You need a GC to free memory the memory that doesn’t have an easily determinable lifetime from static analysis. The way you find the dead objects is by searching the memory graph of the entire application, which is why…

Thanks, everyone! @johnmyleswhite Shows you my ignorance here using vocab I’ve heard but don’t fully understand. I had assumed “old generation” meant no longer used. Thanks for the clarification. @arch.d.robison That’s much clearer now. I read the Go talk and got some of it, but I’ll go back throu…

Why am I wrong about GC?

Internals & Design

Topic		Replies	Views
Poor performance of garbage collection in multi-threaded application Julia at Scale garbage-collection	22	5671	February 3, 2022
Multithreaded GC? Internals & Design garbage-collection , realtime	18	2737	June 16, 2020
Request information about GC implementation Internals & Design question	7	1497	August 9, 2021
Details about Julia's Garbage Collector, Reference Counting? Internals & Design	4	11998	April 27, 2021
Running GC.gc() multiple times General Usage	3	1822	January 29, 2019

Why am I wrong about GC?

Related topics