Hi you all,
Probably the first question and example are too poor to understand my case.
I wrote my situation and what I wanna do in detail below:
Briefly speaking, I wanna save specific variables annotated by a macro (namely, @log
).
More specifically, it is related to logging data in the use of DifferentialEquations.jl (abbrev.: DiffEq).
In DiffEq, I usually write a in-place DE (differential equation) like:
function sub_dynamics1!(dx, x, p, t)
dx .= -1*x # an example dynamics
end
function sub_dynamics2!(dx, x, p, t)
dx .= -2*x # an example dynamics
end
For nested systems, ODE sometimes calls subsystems’ ODE like:
function dynamics!(dx, x, p, t)
sub_dynamics1!(dx.sub1, x.sub1, p.sub1, t)
sub_dynamics2!(dx.sub2, x.sub2, p.sub2, t)
end
Note that the above “dot-access” (I mean, for example, dx.sub1
) is possible via ComponentArrays.jl.
Now, I’d like to add a macro @log
to indicate that the variable will be saved. For example, sub_dyanmics1!
is changed as
function sub_dynamics1!(dx, x, p, t)
@log x # will be saved
dx .= -1*x
end
This idea is based on SimulationLogs.jl. However, as discussed before, SimulationLogs.jl saves data “after simulation”.
This may be undesirable when the update of a simulation parameter (namely, p
) occurs in stochastic sense. Also, I doubt that it works properly in the setting of thread-based parallel simulation.
So I wanna make (possibly some) macros, namely @log
and @LOG
, the former is for annotating saved variables and the latter is to transform dynamics!
into a new function that contains a dictionary (which will contain variables annotated by @log
).
I tested this functionality for some simple examples. The difficulty is, however, when a function (dynamics!
) calls subsystems’ dynamics (sub_dynamics1!
and sub_dynamics2!
) and @log
is added to sub_dynamics1!
and sub_dynamics2!
.
Here are my ideas:
- (probably the best) Make a dictionary, which acts as a global variable only in
dynamics!
(that is, it is merely a local variable outsidedynamics!
and accessible insub_dynamics1!
andsub_dynamics2!
). - (probably safe in terms of thread-based parallel simulation) Make some dictionaries, each of them acts as a global variable only in each thread, and add data to the thread-safe dictionaries.
Do you guys have solutions to my idea? Or, do you have a better idea?
Feel free to leave comments