There are really three wildly different questions here.
- Overall “community sentiment” — this was recently discussed at length in Getting the best out of AI without endangering the community… and I think the topic itself reflects the varied views here quite well.
- How to best review/steer/guide AI generation — there’s a good concurrently ongoing thread in Idiomatic Julia code in AI generated code
- If General should have policies around code quality — there’ve been lots of discussions here, including the one linked above and Should General have a guideline or rule preventing registration of vibe-coded packages?.
@WuSiren what do you want this topic to focus on?