How is the current level of acceptance of AI-generated code within the Julia community, as well as the entire programming community and academic community? Also, for the code generated by AI, is there any good experience in code inspection or any ready-made workflow to verify its correctness?

If I recall something like up to 80% of recent PR to JuliaLang itself have AI assistance (many from CTO Keno). So I would say that much acceptance. By those that merge PRs. There are many vibecoded Julia packages, and people are divided regarding those, and I’ve seen opposition to AI use for JuliaLa…

Thanks. Now I think one issue should be significant that whether we have a standard official workflow that can let Human check for correctness and quality of a julia package. What kind of standardized manual review process should the code undergo before it can be accepted for registration? Do you h…

There was quite a long discussion on a similar topic earlier this year. [image] Policies around registering AI-created packages in General? Tooling I think that Julia discourse should host some discussion about the use of LLM and coding agents in the registere…

There are really three wildly different questions here. Overall “community sentiment” — this was recently discussed at length in Getting the best out of AI without endangering the community … and I think the topic itself reflects the varied views here quite well. How to best review/steer/guide AI g…

Are there any good human experiences in reviewing AI-generated code?

General Usage

mihalybaci September 4, 2026, 4:02pm 4

There was quite a long discussion on a similar topic earlier this year.

Topic		Replies	Views
Policies around registering AI-created packages in General? Tooling package , registry , ai	184	3721	March 19, 2026
JuliaLang/julia is AI slop now and I am heartbroken Community	28	2056	March 29, 2026
Reliability of AI coding tools Offtopic llm	30	1122	November 19, 2025
[Idea/Discussion] A Linter to Fix LLM-Induced Pythonisms in Julia Code – Does it make sense? Community	0	187	November 4, 2025
Getting the best out of AI without endangering the community Community	77	3964	August 22, 2026

Are there any good human experiences in reviewing AI-generated code?

Related topics